Calzaghe Pavlik,who will win? POLL

[rjj tszyu]

Hard one to call. I'd like to see Pavlik fight at SMW before I have to vote on this one because even though I know that he fought Taylor at a catchweight just short of SMW Taylor himself has never fought up at that weight so he can't really be classed as a natural SMW yet and that means that Pavlik has not fought anyone who is a SMW. That said Joe is certainly not getting any younger and Pavlik seems to be getting stronger and stronger so at the moment I think I would just edge it for Pavlik.
(Especially after Joe takes a beating off Roy.)

[Markusdarkus]

I like Pavlik's style a HELL OF A LOT MORE than I do Calzaghe's, but this would not be an easy fight for Pavlik.

Calzaghe, being the wily old veteran that he is, is not going to make this a crowd-pleasing fight. He's going to avoid exchanges like the plague, and use his footwork and hand speed to throw the occasional light-punching flurry at Pavlik. Pavlik, although a wildly entertaining fighter and one of my favorites, can be a bit plodding at times. And Joe will surely try to take advantage of that.

Having said all that, I still voted Pavlik, 'cause it is a 12-round fight, and there's always a chance the crowd will goad Calzaghe into mixing it up with Pavlik, which of course would be his undoing.

Apart from the hopkins fight please list the fights calzaghe has been in that has not been pleasing on the eye? none because Calzaghe is pleasing and will exchange.

He has out war`d more skillful bigger punchers than Kelly Pavlik.

[Markusdarkus]

Work rate is even . Pavlik throws about 80 -110 punches a round. Pavliks punches are accually punches not slaps.
Conditioning goes to Pavlik
Chin ,Pavlik as well
Expirence is all Calzaghe
Power is Pavlik
Heart is most likely a draw.
Height , Pavlik
reach , Pavlik
body attack , Pavlik
speed , Calzaghe but I feel Taylor was faster than Joe has been in the last 4 years.
defense , split
I cant see any other possibility than Joe getting his little ass kicked.

Seriously what a load of crap!

Chin goes to Pavlik? on what basis? theve both been down 3x and Calzaghe has fought bigger tougher men who hit harder than say Zuniga?

Defence Split?
Conditioning Pavlik?
Fanboyism of the highest order.

How about footwork? skill?

Calzaghe owns, the only thing Pavlik has over Calzaghe is power and we will see just how Hard Pavlik hits up at 170lbs, hes not figting 5 8" midgets and in his one fight at SMW he looked far from domanant.

I really hope Pavlik beats Hopkins i pray Joe gets to him quick.

See how Calzaghe fights when he is not fighting overrated euro fighters aqnd old men. Calzaghe has never been close to any one power wise not even Kessler. Hopkins put Calzaghe on his ass with one flush short right. Pavlik took 4 strait hard right from Miranda. One of those punches two fights ago sent a guy threw the ropes. You want to talk about footwork, When has Pavlik ever thrown a punch off balance. You need a good base to deliver power. Calzaghe is weak. His chin is questionable. One shot from Hopkins.
Come one. Pavlik knockout of Calfage by the 9th.

His chin is questionable? how many Calzaghe fights have you seen?

And Hopkins at lightheavy and Kessler at SMW are far better wins than anything pavlik holds, hell Chris Eubank is better than 99% of Pavliks wins.

Calzaghe has an iron chin you can bank on it.

Calzaghe was off balance and unhurt from Hopkins shot, did you see the uppercuts he took from kessler? massive shots a hell of a lot bigger than the right hand Zuniga dropped pavlik with.

[Phil]

Seriously what a load of crap!

Chin goes to Pavlik? on what basis? theve both been down 3x and Calzaghe has fought bigger tougher men who hit harder than say Zuniga?

Defence Split?
Conditioning Pavlik?
Fanboyism of the highest order.

How about footwork? skill?

Calzaghe owns, the only thing Pavlik has over Calzaghe is power and we will see just how Hard Pavlik hits up at 170lbs, hes not figting 5 8" midgets and in his one fight at SMW he looked far from domanant.

I really hope Pavlik beats Hopkins i pray Joe gets to him quick.

See how Calzaghe fights when he is not fighting overrated euro fighters aqnd old men. Calzaghe has never been close to any one power wise not even Kessler. Hopkins put Calzaghe on his ass with one flush short right. Pavlik took 4 strait hard right from Miranda. One of those punches two fights ago sent a guy threw the ropes. You want to talk about footwork, When has Pavlik ever thrown a punch off balance. You need a good base to deliver power. Calzaghe is weak. His chin is questionable. One shot from Hopkins.
Come one. Pavlik knockout of Calfage by the 9th.

His chin is questionable? how many Calzaghe fights have you seen?

And Hopkins at lightheavy and Kessler at SMW are far better wins than anything pavlik holds, hell Chris Eubank is better than 99% of Pavliks wins.

Calzaghe has an iron chin you can bank on it.

Calzaghe was off balance and unhurt from Hopkins shot, did you see the uppercuts he took from kessler? massive shots a hell of a lot bigger than the right hand Zuniga dropped pavlik with.

Agreed Calzaghes chin is grand, Any time he's been down he hasn't been hurt, he took alot of big bombs off Kessler and passed the test, Pavliks chin is pretty solid as well but he was all over the shop against Taylor, so it would be intresting to see how he'd do against big hitting suppermiddle/light heavy guys, don't think Calzaghe's power will trouble him but I think he'd out work him pretty handily

[TitoFan]

I like Pavlik's style a HELL OF A LOT MORE than I do Calzaghe's, but this would not be an easy fight for Pavlik.

Calzaghe, being the wily old veteran that he is, is not going to make this a crowd-pleasing fight. He's going to avoid exchanges like the plague, and use his footwork and hand speed to throw the occasional light-punching flurry at Pavlik. Pavlik, although a wildly entertaining fighter and one of my favorites, can be a bit plodding at times. And Joe will surely try to take advantage of that.

Having said all that, I still voted Pavlik, 'cause it is a 12-round fight, and there's always a chance the crowd will goad Calzaghe into mixing it up with Pavlik, which of course would be his undoing.

Apart from the hopkins fight please list the fights calzaghe has been in that has not been pleasing on the eye? none because Calzaghe is pleasing and will exchange.

He has out war`d more skillful bigger punchers than Kelly Pavlik.

Well, there WAS that memorable battle with the mighty Peter Manfredo.

[ono]

It'v very much dependant on whether or not pavlik can hurt Joe. Providing that Pavlik doesn't land an absolute bomb, i can't see anyway for him to win. I go for Joe and quite comfortably.

I actually feel he'll have a tougher night against Jones.

[Douglas]

Ain't been keepin' up with boxing lately, but I'll half to say Calzaghe. It's really only a guess tho.

[southakron314]

I like Pavlik's style a HELL OF A LOT MORE than I do Calzaghe's, but this would not be an easy fight for Pavlik.

Calzaghe, being the wily old veteran that he is, is not going to make this a crowd-pleasing fight. He's going to avoid exchanges like the plague, and use his footwork and hand speed to throw the occasional light-punching flurry at Pavlik. Pavlik, although a wildly entertaining fighter and one of my favorites, can be a bit plodding at times. And Joe will surely try to take advantage of that.

Having said all that, I still voted Pavlik, 'cause it is a 12-round fight, and there's always a chance the crowd will goad Calzaghe into mixing it up with Pavlik, which of course would be his undoing.

Apart from the hopkins fight please list the fights calzaghe has been in that has not been pleasing on the eye? none because Calzaghe is pleasing and will exchange.

He has out war`d more skillful bigger punchers than Kelly Pavlik.

Who? Who has more accuracy , range and overall power? Kessler , Lacy.... forget about it.

[southakron314]

Seriously what a load of crap!

Chin goes to Pavlik? on what basis? theve both been down 3x and Calzaghe has fought bigger tougher men who hit harder than say Zuniga?

Defence Split?
Conditioning Pavlik?
Fanboyism of the highest order.

How about footwork? skill?

Calzaghe owns, the only thing Pavlik has over Calzaghe is power and we will see just how Hard Pavlik hits up at 170lbs, hes not figting 5 8" midgets and in his one fight at SMW he looked far from domanant.

I really hope Pavlik beats Hopkins i pray Joe gets to him quick.

See how Calzaghe fights when he is not fighting overrated euro fighters aqnd old men. Calzaghe has never been close to any one power wise not even Kessler. Hopkins put Calzaghe on his ass with one flush short right. Pavlik took 4 strait hard right from Miranda. One of those punches two fights ago sent a guy threw the ropes. You want to talk about footwork, When has Pavlik ever thrown a punch off balance. You need a good base to deliver power. Calzaghe is weak. His chin is questionable. One shot from Hopkins.
Come one. Pavlik knockout of Calfage by the 9th.

His chin is questionable? how many Calzaghe fights have you seen?

And Hopkins at lightheavy and Kessler at SMW are far better wins than anything pavlik holds, hell Chris Eubank is better than 99% of Pavliks wins.

Calzaghe has an iron chin you can bank on it.

Calzaghe was off balance and unhurt from Hopkins shot, did you see the uppercuts he took from kessler? massive shots a hell of a lot bigger than the right hand Zuniga dropped pavlik with.

Enough to know that he has been put on his ass by mediocre guys.

[southakron314]

I like Pavlik's style a HELL OF A LOT MORE than I do Calzaghe's, but this would not be an easy fight for Pavlik.

Calzaghe, being the wily old veteran that he is, is not going to make this a crowd-pleasing fight. He's going to avoid exchanges like the plague, and use his footwork and hand speed to throw the occasional light-punching flurry at Pavlik. Pavlik, although a wildly entertaining fighter and one of my favorites, can be a bit plodding at times. And Joe will surely try to take advantage of that.

Having said all that, I still voted Pavlik, 'cause it is a 12-round fight, and there's always a chance the crowd will goad Calzaghe into mixing it up with Pavlik, which of course would be his undoing.

yes lets not forget the worthy Manfredo who lost twice to a super welter weight and once to a welter weight. He lost to a guy who got crushed by a worthy Cotto. Enzo has the balls to say Pavlik isnt worthy. They are coming off a split decision win ( which I thaught was a loss because I dont count arm punches and slaps as landing anything. Hopkins was never hurt or in trouble in that fight. One the other hand Hopkins hurt Joe four times and floored him once and still got raped by the judges. The judges beat Hopkins .. not Calzaghe) agianst a geriatric. I hope Pavlik crushes him in front of his father and country man who travel to Vegas to see their woman fight. I hope he leaves him limp in the ring. This will most likely be a boring fight of Calzaghe running and throwing arm punches and slaps. Pavlik will land flush like always. Well then again he didnt on Lockett and still knocked his sorry ass down time and time again.

Apart from the hopkins fight please list the fights calzaghe has been in that has not been pleasing on the eye? none because Calzaghe is pleasing and will exchange.

He has out war`d more skillful bigger punchers than Kelly Pavlik.

Well, there WAS that memorable battle with the mighty Peter Manfredo.

This pleases me. I will laugh if Jones wins and he retires . Thats how it needs t be. Roy prime for prime was way faster, more powerful , and
comanded the ring better than anyone at 168 or even 160. He was a beautiful fighter in the ring and I am glad for the great years watching him from the time I was a boy until know at 28. Thank you Roy Jones Jr.

[Markusdarkus]

See how Calzaghe fights when he is not fighting overrated euro fighters aqnd old men. Calzaghe has never been close to any one power wise not even Kessler. Hopkins put Calzaghe on his ass with one flush short right. Pavlik took 4 strait hard right from Miranda. One of those punches two fights ago sent a guy threw the ropes. You want to talk about footwork, When has Pavlik ever thrown a punch off balance. You need a good base to deliver power. Calzaghe is weak. His chin is questionable. One shot from Hopkins.
Come one. Pavlik knockout of Calfage by the 9th.

His chin is questionable? how many Calzaghe fights have you seen?

And Hopkins at lightheavy and Kessler at SMW are far better wins than anything pavlik holds, hell Chris Eubank is better than 99% of Pavliks wins.

Calzaghe has an iron chin you can bank on it.

Calzaghe was off balance and unhurt from Hopkins shot, did you see the uppercuts he took from kessler? massive shots a hell of a lot bigger than the right hand Zuniga dropped pavlik with.

Enough to know that he has been put on his ass by mediocre guys.

Calzaghe has been down and never shown to be hurt you keep going on about that its crap. Pavlik has been down the same amount as Joe and Calzaghe has been a pro 11 more yrs than pavlik. Calzaghe has never been out on his feet or hurt Pavlik has, a Welterweight put him down.

This Calzaghe chin business is crap.

[Markusdarkus]

I like Pavlik's style a HELL OF A LOT MORE than I do Calzaghe's, but this would not be an easy fight for Pavlik.

Calzaghe, being the wily old veteran that he is, is not going to make this a crowd-pleasing fight. He's going to avoid exchanges like the plague, and use his footwork and hand speed to throw the occasional light-punching flurry at Pavlik. Pavlik, although a wildly entertaining fighter and one of my favorites, can be a bit plodding at times. And Joe will surely try to take advantage of that.

Having said all that, I still voted Pavlik, 'cause it is a 12-round fight, and there's always a chance the crowd will goad Calzaghe into mixing it up with Pavlik, which of course would be his undoing.

Apart from the hopkins fight please list the fights calzaghe has been in that has not been pleasing on the eye? none because Calzaghe is pleasing and will exchange.

He has out war`d more skillful bigger punchers than Kelly Pavlik.

Well, there WAS that memorable battle with the mighty Peter Manfredo.

Why would you bring Manfredo up? he has nothing to do with what im talking about and all elite fight cans lockett anyone? Sharmba mitchell anyone?

[southakron314]

His chin is questionable? how many Calzaghe fights have you seen?

And Hopkins at lightheavy and Kessler at SMW are far better wins than anything pavlik holds, hell Chris Eubank is better than 99% of Pavliks wins.

Calzaghe has an iron chin you can bank on it.

Calzaghe was off balance and unhurt from Hopkins shot, did you see the uppercuts he took from kessler? massive shots a hell of a lot bigger than the right hand Zuniga dropped pavlik with.

Enough to know that he has been put on his ass by mediocre guys.

Calzaghe has been down and never shown to be hurt you keep going on about that its crap. Pavlik has been down the same amount as Joe and Calzaghe has been a pro 11 more yrs than pavlik. Calzaghe has never been out on his feet or hurt Pavlik has, a Welterweight put him down.

This Calzaghe chin business is crap.

The big one is Pavlik being a retard sticking his chin out and putting his hands by his side to stick his tounge out and he paid. He came back from a ton of punches and left a great champ slumped lifeless in the corner so to say he has a weak chin is shit too. Pavlik has never been down from one clean shot. He slipped with Bronco McKart and they ruled it a knockdown. I dont even count that and he knocked out the former slugger champ out in the middle rounds. Look at the shots he took from Miranda. He was never hurt of even phased. Locket maybee landed one good shot. Locket was a complete joke. He got knocked out from grazing blows just to show you how much power he has. I would say Pavlik jumping to 168 would be the hardest puncher in that class and maybe a top 5 in 175. He is a beast with good defense. great chin. World class conditioning and the heart of Gatti. What is not to like about him. He is like the 1985 chicago bears.

[ssss]

See how Calzaghe fights when he is not fighting overrated euro fighters aqnd old men. Calzaghe has never been close to any one power wise not even Kessler. Hopkins put Calzaghe on his ass with one flush short right. Pavlik took 4 strait hard right from Miranda. One of those punches two fights ago sent a guy threw the ropes. You want to talk about footwork, When has Pavlik ever thrown a punch off balance. You need a good base to deliver power. Calzaghe is weak. His chin is questionable. One shot from Hopkins.
Come one. Pavlik knockout of Calfage by the 9th.

His chin is questionable? how many Calzaghe fights have you seen?

And Hopkins at lightheavy and Kessler at SMW are far better wins than anything pavlik holds, hell Chris Eubank is better than 99% of Pavliks wins.

Calzaghe has an iron chin you can bank on it.

Calzaghe was off balance and unhurt from Hopkins shot, did you see the uppercuts he took from kessler? massive shots a hell of a lot bigger than the right hand Zuniga dropped pavlik with.

Agreed Calzaghes chin is grand, Any time he's been down he hasn't been hurt, he took alot of big bombs off Kessler and passed the test, Pavliks chin is pretty solid as well but he was all over the shop against Taylor, so it would be intresting to see how he'd do against big hitting suppermiddle/light heavy guys, don't think Calzaghe's power will trouble him but I think he'd out work him pretty handily

calzaghe was pretty shaken up when he got dropped by big right hand from salem

[Markusdarkus]

Enough to know that he has been put on his ass by mediocre guys.

Calzaghe has been down and never shown to be hurt you keep going on about that its crap. Pavlik has been down the same amount as Joe and Calzaghe has been a pro 11 more yrs than pavlik. Calzaghe has never been out on his feet or hurt Pavlik has, a Welterweight put him down.

This Calzaghe chin business is crap.

The big one is Pavlik being a retard sticking his chin out and putting his hands by his side to stick his tounge out and he paid. He came back from a ton of punches and left a great champ slumped lifeless in the corner so to say he has a weak chin is shit too. Pavlik has never been down from one clean shot. He slipped with Bronco McKart and they ruled it a knockdown. I dont even count that and he knocked out the former slugger champ out in the middle rounds. Look at the shots he took from Miranda. He was never hurt of even phased. Locket maybee landed one good shot. Locket was a complete joke. He got knocked out from grazing blows just to show you how much power he has. I would say Pavlik jumping to 168 would be the hardest puncher in that class and maybe a top 5 in 175. He is a beast with good defense. great chin. World class conditioning and the heart of Gatti. What is not to like about him. He is like the 1985 chicago bears.

I like Pavlik he is very exciting its just the guys that follow him and choose to make up crap about every opponent between 160-175 yet deny Pavlik has any weakness.

Im not saying Kelly has a weak him but someone said his chin is better than Calzaghes, im mearly stating on what basis.

That said i still think Joe will "slap" his way to a masterclass.