I think this showed how much best ODLH is than Mosley at this point

[Taeth]

Mosley didn't even look close to as good as De La HOya dida gainst Mayorga. I know this isn't the best fighter for him to face, but he wasn't able to control the fight half as much as Oscar did.... I am glad for Cotto's sake that he didn't face Oscar after Margarito.

[mike_tha_man]

yeah agree with the fact that Mosley didn't look nearly as good against Mayorga as De la Hoya did. i still don't know if i would say I'm glad Cotto didn't fight Oscar, but it would have been a great fight. styles make fights

[Rotten Apple]

Mosley's best days are behind him. I think it's best if he retires. I would hate see to him take a bad beating by some young fighter he would of toyed with in his prime

[GAME]

All it showed was that Oscar at this stage is more comfortable at 154 . t doesnt mean he is better cuz they could meet at 147 again and Mosley could school him . . . . . again

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

Despite what all you guys think, i still think Oscar looses to Cotto and Shane at 147.

[Taeth]

All it showed was that Oscar at this stage is more comfortable at 154 . t doesnt mean he is better cuz they could meet at 147 again and Mosley could school him . . . . . again

Give me a break, Mosley didn't school him in either fight, and he certainly didn't win the second fight. It isn't about Oscar being more comfortable at 154. Its about Mosley only relying on speed, while Oscar has speed along with a lot better boxing skills. If Mosley outboxed Mayorga as dramatically as oscar did I would agree that he didn't take Mayorga out later being of the weight, but he clearly wasn't even boxing all that well.

[Taeth]

Despite what all you guys think, i still think Oscar looses to Cotto and Shane at 147.

He would knock Cotto out, I love Cotto, but Oscar is the hardest hitter he would face in his career, and the best fighter. Oscar is a faster, he has a better chin, he is bigger, he has a similar style to Cotto.

Don't get me wrong if Cotto had better durability I think he beats Oscar, Mosley, Margarito, anyone else except Floyd, but he doesn't, so all these guys that can take shots and hit harder then Mosley IMO are stoping Cotto.

[CutMeMick]

Quite simple...

1. Size difference (if you didn't see it your blind)
2. Styles make fights





Anyone who judges SSM on last nights fight is blind IMO.

[Kev]

Quite simple...

1. Size difference (if you didn't see it your blind)
2. Styles make fights





Anyone who judges SSM on last nights fight is blind IMO.

I agree with Mick on this, Mosely is much smaller than Oscar who has even fought at 160, so Mayorga's size was always going to be a problem. In the ring they looked two weight classes apart.

Also, and something nobody else has mentioned, but I think Mayorga was FAR more prepared, physically and mentally for this fight than he was against Oscar.

Oscar didn't beat the version of Mayorga that Mosely did.

Also compare how flat and shit Oscar looked against Steve Forbes to Mosely's display against Cotto and Collazo and you really can't say Mosely has slipped much.

He's still world class, took on and beat a real strong determined fighter in Mayorga who outweighted him by almost a full stone on the night.

[Taeth]

lol, Oscar didn't look flat at all againt Forbes... He was moving well the whole night, following in behind his jab, he was throwing excellent combinations, and he was going to the body well. The one thing I think hurt him was he underestimated Forbes speed, or decided Forbes couldn't hurt him at all, so he abandoned defense a bit in that fight.

Oscar made Mayorga look worse, it wasn't because Mayorga came in better against Mosley. I am not talking about the fact that Oscar ko'ed him earlier as much as Oscar was much better defensively against Mayorga, his movement was better, he actually had a jab to control Mayorga's offense, he was countering better.

Obviously he hit harder as well, but in terms of who was landing cleaner shots, while not getting hit by clean shots, Oscar wins hands down. That has nothing to do with size. Oscar beat Mayorga more emphatically than Trinidad as well who is larger than Oscar.

Also lets look at Mosley-COllazo, before Collazo broke his hand it sure looked close. He was matching Mosley's speed, and he was countering him, but as soon as he broke that left hand he stopped throwing any punches which Emmanuel commented on the whole night. Mosley looked good that night, but against Cotto I don't think he looked good at all. Cotto outtimed him, outpunched him, and was the better man. The only credit I gave Mosley was that he has his invulnerability and he walked through a few halacious punches, and he land that right hand which is the one punch he has managed to retain.

Personally, I have never found Mosley to be as good as everyone has. I think he was a gifted athlete who was tought poorly how to fight, and that his athletic ability more than his skills have continued to push him through. I think if he had, had a less granite chin, he wouldn't have achieved half of what he did north of the lightweight division.

[Kev]

lol, Oscar didn't look flat at all againt Forbes... He was moving well the whole night, following in behind his jab, he was throwing excellent combinations, and he was going to the body well. The one thing I think hurt him was he underestimated Forbes speed, or decided Forbes couldn't hurt him at all, so he abandoned defense a bit in that fight.

Oscar made Mayorga look worse, it wasn't because Mayorga came in better against Mosley. I am not talking about the fact that Oscar ko'ed him earlier as much as Oscar was much better defensively against Mayorga, his movement was better, he actually had a jab to control Mayorga's offense, he was countering better.

Obviously he hit harder as well, but in terms of who was landing cleaner shots, while not getting hit by clean shots, Oscar wins hands down. That has nothing to do with size. Oscar beat Mayorga more emphatically than Trinidad as well who is larger than Oscar.

Also lets look at Mosley-COllazo, before Collazo broke his hand it sure looked close. He was matching Mosley's speed, and he was countering him, but as soon as he broke that left hand he stopped throwing any punches which Emmanuel commented on the whole night. Mosley looked good that night, but against Cotto I don't think he looked good at all. Cotto outtimed him, outpunched him, and was the better man. The only credit I gave Mosley was that he has his invulnerability and he walked through a few halacious punches, and he land that right hand which is the one punch he has managed to retain.

Personally, I have never found Mosley to be as good as everyone has. I think he was a gifted athlete who was tought poorly how to fight, and that his athletic ability more than his skills have continued to push him through. I think if he had, had a less granite chin, he wouldn't have achieved half of what he did north of the lightweight division.

lol I found myself disagreeing with every single line of this post

[CutMeMick]

lol, Oscar didn't look flat at all againt Forbes... He was moving well the whole night, following in behind his jab, he was throwing excellent combinations, and he was going to the body well. The one thing I think hurt him was he underestimated Forbes speed, or decided Forbes couldn't hurt him at all, so he abandoned defense a bit in that fight.

Oscar made Mayorga look worse, it wasn't because Mayorga came in better against Mosley. I am not talking about the fact that Oscar ko'ed him earlier as much as Oscar was much better defensively against Mayorga, his movement was better, he actually had a jab to control Mayorga's offense, he was countering better.

Obviously he hit harder as well, but in terms of who was landing cleaner shots, while not getting hit by clean shots, Oscar wins hands down. That has nothing to do with size. Oscar beat Mayorga more emphatically than Trinidad as well who is larger than Oscar.

Also lets look at Mosley-COllazo, before Collazo broke his hand it sure looked close. He was matching Mosley's speed, and he was countering him, but as soon as he broke that left hand he stopped throwing any punches which Emmanuel commented on the whole night. Mosley looked good that night, but against Cotto I don't think he looked good at all. Cotto outtimed him, outpunched him, and was the better man. The only credit I gave Mosley was that he has his invulnerability and he walked through a few halacious punches, and he land that right hand which is the one punch he has managed to retain.

Personally, I have never found Mosley to be as good as everyone has. I think he was a gifted athlete who was tought poorly how to fight, and that his athletic ability more than his skills have continued to push him through. I think if he had, had a less granite chin, he wouldn't have achieved half of what he did north of the lightweight division.

You know as I read this I was thinking OK, he's got some valid points...

Then you end it with that sentece...

"IF"...

If my grandma had wheels she'd be bike.

I that case I'm gonna say:
"If Berto didn't have the hand speed he has he would have lost to Forbes"

[Markusdarkus]

Mosley didn't even look close to as good as De La HOya dida gainst Mayorga. I know this isn't the best fighter for him to face, but he wasn't able to control the fight half as much as Oscar did.... I am glad for Cotto's sake that he didn't face Oscar after Margarito.

Oscar chose to counter punch and fight off a good hard jab. Mosley just went in thinking he could bomb Mayorga out and found his timing was off.

Lets hope Shane sticks to 147 and works off his jab he is getting involved in to many wars.

[Tysonbruno]

I think its more of a styles make fights

[Markusdarkus]

I think its more of a styles make fights

I just thought Shane looked poor his timing was miles off.