Did Cotto get shafted?

[jamiebhoy]

exactly. now all floyd has to do is fight someone his own size. mosley who called him out or pac-cotto winner.

both would be ideal. but winner of pac-cotto.

Thing is if PAC beats Cotto, Mayweather is in another lose/lose situation in facing PAC. Either he loses to a smaller man OR he beats yet another smaller man. If he fights Mosley and he wins, he has beat an over the hill Mosley. The only fights that Mayweather gets credit for are Cotto IF he beats PAC or Paul Williams IF he can still make 147.

Agree to a certain extent, however he would be a little more justified in saying that a fight with Pac was effectively by public demand which would be true so the fact he is smaller wouldn't appear as relevant.

Mosley , well he could say if he beats him "he called me out i knew i would get him " blah blah again he would be justified in answering a call out.

The other two options are the preferred in terms of an honest fight and a test for him.I would like to see Williams if as you say he can make the weight, but then what does weight matter these days !!!

[killersheep]

both would be ideal. but winner of pac-cotto.

Thing is if PAC beats Cotto, Mayweather is in another lose/lose situation in facing PAC. Either he loses to a smaller man OR he beats yet another smaller man. If he fights Mosley and he wins, he has beat an over the hill Mosley. The only fights that Mayweather gets credit for are Cotto IF he beats PAC or Paul Williams IF he can still make 147.

Agree to a certain extent, however he would be a little more justified in saying that a fight with Pac was effectively by public demand which would be true so the fact he is smaller wouldn't appear as relevant.

Mosley , well he could say if he beats him "he called me out i knew i would get him " blah blah again he would be justified in answering a call out.

The other two options are the preferred in terms of an honest fight and a test for him.I would like to see Williams if as you say he can make the weight, but then what does weight matter these days !!!

Marquez called out Floyd as well though, Floyd said this was a tune-up fight, Marquez took the money and agreed to fight on Floyd's terms. Let's be honest here there is very little Floyd could do to not have any excuses made for his victories save the two I mentioned. The fact that PAC is smaller would most definately become relevant after the fight, there is no way you could think that if PAC were to lose to Mayweather the weight issue would not be brought up. Same with Mosley you really think if PBF beats Mosley the age thing won't get brought up?

[Rantcatrat]

both would be ideal. but winner of pac-cotto.

Thing is if PAC beats Cotto, Mayweather is in another lose/lose situation in facing PAC. Either he loses to a smaller man OR he beats yet another smaller man. If he fights Mosley and he wins, he has beat an over the hill Mosley. The only fights that Mayweather gets credit for are Cotto IF he beats PAC or Paul Williams IF he can still make 147.

Agree to a certain extent, however he would be a little more justified in saying that a fight with Pac was effectively by public demand which would be true so the fact he is smaller wouldn't appear as relevant.

Mosley , well he could say if he beats him "he called me out i knew i would get him " blah blah again he would be justified in answering a call out.

The other two options are the preferred in terms of an honest fight and a test for him.I would like to see Williams if as you say he can make the weight, but then what does weight matter these days !!!

Didn't Floyd fight ODLH at 154? If that is the case, he could fight Pwill there too.

[Rantcatrat]

Thing is if PAC beats Cotto, Mayweather is in another lose/lose situation in facing PAC. Either he loses to a smaller man OR he beats yet another smaller man. If he fights Mosley and he wins, he has beat an over the hill Mosley. The only fights that Mayweather gets credit for are Cotto IF he beats PAC or Paul Williams IF he can still make 147.

Agree to a certain extent, however he would be a little more justified in saying that a fight with Pac was effectively by public demand which would be true so the fact he is smaller wouldn't appear as relevant.

Mosley , well he could say if he beats him "he called me out i knew i would get him " blah blah again he would be justified in answering a call out.

The other two options are the preferred in terms of an honest fight and a test for him.I would like to see Williams if as you say he can make the weight, but then what does weight matter these days !!!

Marquez called out Floyd as well though, Floyd said this was a tune-up fight, Marquez took the money and agreed to fight on Floyd's terms. Let's be honest here there is very little Floyd could do to not have any excuses made for his victories save the two I mentioned. The fact that PAC is smaller would most definately become relevant after the fight, there is no way you could think that if PAC were to lose to Mayweather the weight issue would not be brought up. Same with Mosley you really think if PBF beats Mosley the age thing won't get brought up?

Maybe, but not as much. Mosley looked sharp in his last fight and has looked sharp in a few fights recently. For competitiveness sake, I'd rather see a PBF v. SSM fight than a Pac v. PBF fight.

[fan johnny]

Mayweather is a better fighter than Cotto, I think it should affect the p4p status of him for sure, but IMO divisional rankings should be based on competition, or else the p4p king would jump to the top of any new weightclass they entered, one thing however that I give Mayweather credit for is that he has been the linear welterweight champion before and Cotto hasn't. Mayweather undefeated as a welterweight, Cotto isn't.

Mayweather is a better outside boxer, not a better fighter. He has to prove he is the better fighter by who he fights inside the ring to get that label. Face Mosley, Margarito, Williams and get that recognition with actions not words.

[C-Lo]

Thing is if PAC beats Cotto, Mayweather is in another lose/lose situation in facing PAC. Either he loses to a smaller man OR he beats yet another smaller man. If he fights Mosley and he wins, he has beat an over the hill Mosley. The only fights that Mayweather gets credit for are Cotto IF he beats PAC or Paul Williams IF he can still make 147.

Agree to a certain extent, however he would be a little more justified in saying that a fight with Pac was effectively by public demand which would be true so the fact he is smaller wouldn't appear as relevant.

Mosley , well he could say if he beats him "he called me out i knew i would get him " blah blah again he would be justified in answering a call out.

The other two options are the preferred in terms of an honest fight and a test for him.I would like to see Williams if as you say he can make the weight, but then what does weight matter these days !!!

Didn't Floyd fight ODLH at 154? If that is the case, he could fight Pwill there too.

He went that high because of the mega payday. He wouldn't get enough money to go back there by fighting Williams. Boxing fans would look forward to it, but the general public would not pay to see Paul Williams.

[KKisser]

yeah, but they would pay to see floyd up against a real challenge and fighting williams at 154 would be a hell of a challenge, although i doubt floyd would take it.

[killersheep]

yeah, but they would pay to see floyd up against a real challenge and fighting williams at 154 would be a hell of a challenge, although i doubt floyd would take it.

Williams at 154? Never happen.

Case 1. Williams beats Pavlik and then he will have all the bargaining chips to fight anyone at 160 and have the percentages in his favor (at least against any othe Middleweight). It will clearly show a dominant size differential that in no way, shape or form would get Floyd into the ring with.

Case 2. Pavlik beats Williams and Williams has very little bargaining power.

Either case, the risk/reward ratio isn't there realistically. If Williams weigh's 154 at the weigh in he will be over 170 on fight night and still have a reach longer than the Klitschkos. To have that option against the possibilities of Pacquiao/Cotto winner, Mosley, Berto, Margarito (when he comes back) all have a much better risk/reward ratio.

[PRIDE OF BOSTON]

Cotto sits abreast the division to the people that count. Floyd deserves to be at the top of the rankings but in truth, beating a blown up Jr. Lightweight in the Welterweight division, nomatter how highly regarded should not dictate a spot at the top. Does his talent level say he belongs there? You'd be hardpressed to find someone to say no... But the fact remains that prior to fighting this last "welterweight" contest he was inactive for 2 years. He should not be ahead of Cotto.