Why not Cotto vs Margarito II

[Julius Rain]

I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.

[0james0]

It would be a huge match, but would Cotto take it on?

I don't think Margarito should be in any fights, let alone all of these massive ones he's being banded around for.

But I would like to see Cotto avenge that loss.

[No Contest]

If they make it at 154, Cotto gets the lion share of the purse big time, then I'll be ok with it.

[Chino]

If they make it at 154, Cotto gets the lion share of the purse big time, then I'll be ok with it.

I find it a bit ridiculous for Pac and his team to be looking for Cotto II just to score another easy weight title. Even worse, to see Pac fans totally rooting for that fight. It's not so much because "Oh my gawd, that will be such a great fight" but more like "There's an easy opportunity to win another weight title, go go go".

I thought boxing fans enjoyed seeing challenging fights not just easy fights.

[Lance Uppercut]

I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.

I believe that was arum's plan if pacman maywhehter was made.

[Master]

would much prefer to see Cotto v Pac man 2 with no restrictions on weight, I believe Cotto stands a good chance.

[JonesJrMayweather]

[QUOTE=Julius Rain;892629]I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.[/QUOTEB

Before reading the the entire post I got as far as the bold part and thought (only the cotto supporters have questions) then continued to read came to your last statement and it was confirmed.

The fight would be the exact same except Marga would finish him earlier because he'd be out to prove that he didn't need bricks to beat Cotto, and after Cotto realizes that he cant hurt Margarito he'll quit or his corner will....

[ICB]

[QUOTE=JonesJrMayweather;892879]

I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.[/QUOTEB

Before reading the the entire post I got as far as the bold part and thought (only the cotto supporters have questions) then continued to read came to your last statement and it was confirmed.

The fight would be the exact same except Marga would finish him earlier because he'd be out to prove that he didn't need bricks to beat Cotto, and after Cotto realizes that he cant hurt Margarito he'll quit or his corner will....

No there's question marks because Antonio Margarito in his last fight, showed none of the thudding power he did in fights against Golden Johnson or ETC. Infact his punches looked quite weak IMO, and he never came close to stopping his opponent who was mediocre at best.

And this was the same guy who almost tore off Sebastian Andres Lujan's ear, destroyed Golden Johnson in 1 round with a terrfic show of power. And busted Miguel Cotto's face up totally.

Yet in the 2 fights we knew he was actually legit in, his thudding power seemed to disappear. Coincidence ? i think not.

[JonesJrMayweather]

[QUOTE=ICB;892890]

I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.[/QUOTEB

Before reading the the entire post I got as far as the bold part and thought (only the cotto supporters have questions) then continued to read came to your last statement and it was confirmed.

The fight would be the exact same except Marga would finish him earlier because he'd be out to prove that he didn't need bricks to beat Cotto, and after Cotto realizes that he cant hurt Margarito he'll quit or his corner will....

No there's question marks because Antonio Margarito in his last fight, showed none of the thudding power he did in fights against Golden Johnson or ETC. Infact his punches looked quite weak IMO, and he never came close to stopping his opponent who was mediocre at best.

And this was the same guy who almost tore off Sebastian Andres Lujan's ear, destroyed Golden Johnson in 1 round with a terrfic show of power. And busted Miguel Cotto's face up totally.

Yet in the 2 fights we knew he was actually legit in, his thudding power seemed to disappear. Coincidence ? i think not.

He didnt get land anything on Mosley and mosley smothered the shit out of him.

He was legit in the cotto fight as well. Go watch the tape, see for yourself as kenny bayless grabs him by the hand with his wraps still on, watch cotto shake his hand with the wraps on. Now if they were supposedly hard as cement wouldn't they have noticed? Did he have bricks in his face that allowed him to walk cotto down? WAs manny and judah roided out because they busted him too. Hell even Paulie gave Cotto swelling....

[Puerto Rican Punch]

Now that Cotto is training with Emanuel I see him a lot more focused, I would say a new Cotto. If he had this type of focus earlier in his career I guess he could be another Tito in Puerto Rico, and probably would not have those brutal losses (could loose, but probably in a different way). Now Cotto is more open in interviews, he is studying the fighters before the fight, watching tapes after the fight to study his mistakes, which is something that he would never do before. A totally different Cotto (thanks Emanuel). My question is how much he could be affected psycologically after those loses. Other than that, I think Cotto can score a big win with Margarito, but to be honest I don't mind if Margarito never fight again after that cheeting. But by the way, Cotto has opened the doors for that re-match.

With Pacman... still a tough one, but I guess it could be a lot more competitive making a different fight style. I think Cotto believe that with one big punch he could finish Pacman and he and his team were totally wrong. If Cotto had box better in the early rounds he could probably hurt Pacman late in the fight. With that said, I wish Cotto has a second chance with Pacman and see what happens (no restrictions in weight, training with Emanuel ).

[ICB]

[QUOTE=JonesJrMayweather;892897]

I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.[/QUOTEB

Before reading the the entire post I got as far as the bold part and thought (only the cotto supporters have questions) then continued to read came to your last statement and it was confirmed.

The fight would be the exact same except Marga would finish him earlier because he'd be out to prove that he didn't need bricks to beat Cotto, and after Cotto realizes that he cant hurt Margarito he'll quit or his corner will....

No there's question marks because Antonio Margarito in his last fight, showed none of the thudding power he did in fights against Golden Johnson or ETC. Infact his punches looked quite weak IMO, and he never came close to stopping his opponent who was mediocre at best.

And this was the same guy who almost tore off Sebastian Andres Lujan's ear, destroyed Golden Johnson in 1 round with a terrfic show of power. And busted Miguel Cotto's face up totally.

Yet in the 2 fights we knew he was actually legit in, his thudding power seemed to disappear. Coincidence ? i think not.

He didnt get land anything on Mosley and mosley smothered the shit out of him.

He was legit in the cotto fight as well. Go watch the tape, see for yourself as kenny bayless grabs him by the hand with his wraps still on, watch cotto shake his hand with the wraps on. Now if they were supposedly hard as cement wouldn't they have noticed? Did he have bricks in his face that allowed him to walk cotto down? WAs manny and judah roided out because they busted him too. Hell even Paulie gave Cotto swelling....

Did you see Antonio Margarito's last fight ? just wondering.

[JonesJrMayweather]

[QUOTE=ICB;892993]

I know many dont want to see Tony earn another big payday but IMO a rematch should be demanded because of the question marks surrounding the result of the first fight.

They can have the fight in Puerto Rico or Mexico. I think that could be huge. I personally believe Cotto avenges his lost in a very brutal fashion.[/QUOTEB

Before reading the the entire post I got as far as the bold part and thought (only the cotto supporters have questions) then continued to read came to your last statement and it was confirmed.

The fight would be the exact same except Marga would finish him earlier because he'd be out to prove that he didn't need bricks to beat Cotto, and after Cotto realizes that he cant hurt Margarito he'll quit or his corner will....

No there's question marks because Antonio Margarito in his last fight, showed none of the thudding power he did in fights against Golden Johnson or ETC. Infact his punches looked quite weak IMO, and he never came close to stopping his opponent who was mediocre at best.

And this was the same guy who almost tore off Sebastian Andres Lujan's ear, destroyed Golden Johnson in 1 round with a terrfic show of power. And busted Miguel Cotto's face up totally.

Yet in the 2 fights we knew he was actually legit in, his thudding power seemed to disappear. Coincidence ? i think not.

He didnt get land anything on Mosley and mosley smothered the shit out of him.

He was legit in the cotto fight as well. Go watch the tape, see for yourself as kenny bayless grabs him by the hand with his wraps still on, watch cotto shake his hand with the wraps on. Now if they were supposedly hard as cement wouldn't they have noticed? Did he have bricks in his face that allowed him to walk cotto down? WAs manny and judah roided out because they busted him too. Hell even Paulie gave Cotto swelling....

Did you see Antonio Margarito's last fight ? just wondering.

Nah, didnt see it. I'll watch it now though. But let's no forget he'd been away for year and I heard he won every round...but I'll go DL it now...

[BoxingGorilla]

I figure that Margarito fighting again is okay with me. I've gotten over the incident. Still, I'd rather seem him face new opponents then hear all the speculation that would come with Cotto Vs. Margarito II.

Besides if Cotto would lose again then Margarito's blemish would be lifted in a sense. I'd puke.

[jolz]

If they make it at 154, Cotto gets the lion share of the purse big time, then I'll be ok with it.

I find it a bit ridiculous for Pac and his team to be looking for Cotto II just to score another easy weight title. Even worse, to see Pac fans totally rooting for that fight. It's not so much because "Oh my gawd, that will be such a great fight" but more like "There's an easy opportunity to win another weight title, go go go".

I thought boxing fans enjoyed seeing challenging fights not just easy fights.

Just make Pacquiao fight @ 140..

[CutMeMick]

IMO...
Because Margarito should never be allowed to fight again.

Less we forget Resto-Collins?
Thank god it didn't end that way but it could have...