Tactical defending would make the game more realistic if player movements were implemented properly.

More often than not, i find that i can be as patient as i want, but as soon as i select a player to make a tackle, or at least close the ball down, the rest of the defence (controlled by the AI) will repell against eachother, thus creating a big gap for their striker to run through. It's happened in nearly every Fifa game i've ever played so it's not a new problem.

That aside, Fifa 12 is good this year. I'm enjoying it.

I played the PES12 demo (only the 1st one) and i enjoyed that aswell. I'll more than likely buy PES12 on the PC because of all of the modding. PES12 just has a nice feeling about it. Players aren't over responsive like they are on Fifa. I just wish they could fix the keepers.