I also think number 3 is best if your footwork or overall ability isnt matched, maybe hes faster, if you feel he has better boxing skills, which it sounds like he may have, best to work simple with this kind of fighter and work your strengths not his, kid the left hook on catch it and send 2 (hes square for it)-3, 3-2 or 2-3-4b back 2-3-3b, see where hes exposed after shots and pick your counters accordingly, depends how you wanna catch or stop/evade it but left cut to the body is what you really want to establish seen as he's leading with his liver. jab high on the forehead when you suspect hes going to parry and return with a left hook, weave the hook then throw a straight right over top. then jab him to the chest or shoulder to mess him up even further/not to dedicate yet incase hes going to move out and follow up on it sharply because he'll be square to you, dont let him regain composure, straight rights, hooks, job lot off of the jab. dont let him predict your jab to such a level, bend knees and jab low, bend the knees and jab high, fighting is all about psychodynamics and it sounds like hes got you sussed more than you have him, feinting is priceless when your being countered. hope some of this helps just a quick post.