Who was the best british/irish middle/supermiddle ?

[WWatt]

1) Eubank
2) Graham
3) Calzaghe
4) Benn
5) Watson
6) Collins

How can you have somebody that failed at each world title attempt ahead of somebody who is the longest reigning world champion in world boxing??

Don't get me wrong I loved Bomber, but he is only that high on any list due to talent and potential not achievement

Exactly. It's asking for 'best', not 'top'.

Benn is the best achievement-wise. I think Eubank is the biggest waste of talent.