Tito Trinidad all the way. Tito is 5'11, Shane is 5'8/5'9, the fighters that beat Shane were tall, utilized distance well, and had good jabs much like Tito (Oscar could have and should have beaten Shane). At the time Shane fought Winky he wasn't moving his head as well, his upper body was stiff, and his combination punching wasn't as effective. Plus at 154 Shane just wasn't as good of a fighter as he was at 135-147...what made Shane successful there didn't work as well at 154.

If Tito was going to get handled by someone at 154 in a comeback it would have been De la Hoya II because he would have outboxed him for 12 and maybe gone for a late stoppage instead of coasting like he did in the first fight.


No disrespect to Shane though, great fighter.....greater at 135 than anywhere else, but still great fighter.