How is Calzaghe overrated? I mean how highly is he rated? Most people rate him as the greatest 168 of all time but that division isn't stacked historically. Roy Jones is probably the best of all time at that division but didn't stick around long enough there. I think even the most staunch Calzaghe supporters would acknowledge that. I don't think anyone puts him at top 10 of all time or anything. Hes a great fighter, would you care to propose a fighter who had a better body of work at 168?