Yes, he is no John Marston. I actually prefer the original RDR so far. The new one is nice but it is clunky and Mark is right that you spend hours on a horse just holding the X button. After Spiderman and the smoothness and fantastic controls this is a bit annoying sometimes. Rockstar needs to improve its control system. I couldn't give a hoot about petting a horse or changing clothes for weather either. I'm a wild man I can take the cold. In real life too. This isn't The Sims. I never played those kinds of games.