who's to say calzaghe couldnt take tarvers punches? he's taken punches from other opponents and remained firmly intact. never close to being ko'ed. jones went 12 rounds with tarver, johnson went the distance twice, there is nothing to suggest that calzaghe couldnt outwork tarver for a clear decision and eat a few punches on the way...calzaghe can fight non stop, tarver cant. he has stamina issues. he's coming down after heavily bulking up. and he's ageing.

i maintain that calzaghe beats tarver at this stage in the game....