How about a "where did it all go wrong" award...to be presented in the ceremony by Mike Tyson of course.
My nominations would be:
Juan Manuel Marquez - losing to Chris John and then two rather laborious wins in 2006.
Rudy Markussen - In line for a mandatory challenge against Calzaghe, then blows it in an 8 rounder against some unheralded Russian.
Ike Quartey - The year that his comeback hit the rails in a big way. An unlucky loss against Vernon Forrest, but a generous Winky Wright lets him go the 12.
Zab Judah - Two defeats on the bounce in title bouts, and nothing much heard from him in recent months.

Any other nominees?