Quote Originally Posted by Unknowndonor
Good read. Good arguments. IMO Floyd, Wright, and Pac should be everyones top 3 p4p. You can battle all day about who should be one. I give Winky the edge because of his recent comp. You can say the same about Pac, but he stays at three because of the loss to Morrales{that loss is an honorable one, to say the least}. Floyd gets an advantage because of 0 losses. If Floyd and Wright lose their next matches{especially if they are close}, they still stay in the top ten because of who they lost to. Which would catapult Pac to 1. If both Floyd and Wright win, It's a hard choice. Even though I'm a Floyd fan, I give the nod to Wright. Mosely twice, Soliman,Tito, and Taylor. Noone else in boxing at this time can say they have defeated a string of opponents like that. X- Factor= If Wright wins a SD or anything close, and Floyd demolishes Zab{we'll say inside five}, does Floyd get credit? Or does everyone chalk it up as Zab is washed up? Only time will tell. Regardless, Pac, Floyd, and Wright are 1,2,and 3 p4p.
Gotta agree with ya, although Winky's poor showing against Soliman, despite the win gave me doubts, but still it's gotta be those three at the top, probably followed by some combination of Hatton, Calzaghe and Barrera. My top 10 goes Winky, PBF, Pacman, Barrera, Hatton, Calzaghe, Castillo, Ivan Calderon, Taylor, Bell