Quote Originally Posted by Unknowndonor
At one time, Mosely was 1 p4p, and Tito was two, Roy was third. If those two fighters hadn't been undefeated at the time, would they still be ranked higher than Roy? Mosely had beat Oscar, but skipped 140 almost altogether. Why was he #1. Tito had beaten everyone convincingly{with the exception of Oscar}. So why was Mosely #1 on everyone's list, when after Oscar, he was fighting nobodys? Times have changed, but at that time, Tito {pre-Hopkins}, should have been #1,IMO.
Thanks for making me think about Oscar!! You could say he won both the Tito fight and the 2nd Mosely fight when Shane was the popular pick as p4p1! He moves up another weight wins a world title and is competitive against Hopkins. Mosely won his 1st title at Lightweight, Dela Hoya won his at Super Featherweight, Floyd also won his Super Featherweight, could any of you see Floyd doing a better job against the Sturm and Hopkins that Oscar fought? By rights Oscar has more claim to number 1 than Floyd.

Quote Originally Posted by Unknowndonor
beating Tszyu, and who, oh, Maussa. Is nopt the same as beating Corrales,Castilllo 2 times,N'dou, skip the next guy, Gatti {on a hot streak}, and Mitchell.
I dont blame Floyd for not fighting Hatton at all but I'm not going to give him any more credit or a higher position p4p than he earnt back in 2002. The beating Hatton put on the version of Kostya that destroyed Sharmba is p4p worthy! Kostya was top 5 p4p. Where on your p4p list did you have Corrales, Castillo, N'dou and Gatti when Floyd fought them?