That's like saying if Hopkins were to beat Winky in a competitive fight in July, Id have to decide which one should still be on the top 10 p4p?? Rubbish. I thought Hopkins wen't 1-1 with Taylor. Im not just going by paper, I felt Hopkins won the first fight, and I feel he's a better fighter than Taylor.. He just struggled with making 160 for a long time and fought too conservatively in general. And no, of course Clinton Woods beating Tarver wouldn't put him in the top 10 p4p, unless Tarver had a good win beforehand to get back on track, then Woods proceeded to put on a masterful boxing performance. But guess what... He can't, because he isn't as good as Hopkins. THat's all Im saying, my top 10 p4p is in my opinion the 10 best boxers in the world.. You still haven't said why Hopkins or Taylor shouldn't be in the top 10.. Who should be instead?? Since you admit you don't think Hatton should, Id like to hear.. Anyways CC, we've had some good debates recently.