ALL TIME??
Does everyone realize how long "All time" is?? It's... well... ALL TIME!
I didn't see a time frame in the thread, so I'm just assuming all time.
Modern day in the last 20 years or so, definitely throw him in that list.
But if we're talking all time, Oscar is barely a blip on the p4p list.
I have nothing against Oscar and I love that he fights everyone out there.
But I'm talking ALL TIME.
If you have Oscar in your top30 all time p4p, consider some names of the last... well... all time number of years...
SRR
Ali
Armstrong
Sweet Pea
Greb
RJJ
Duran
SRL
Arguello
JCC
Ezzard Charles
Willie Pep
Marciano
Louis
Tunney
Benny Leonard
Hagler
Archie Moore
PBF
Holyfield
Hearns
Hopkins
Jimmy Wilde
Benitez
Langford
Fitzsimmons
Attel
Jersey Joe
Dempsey
Jack Johnson

That's just 30 off the top of my head. I'm sure there are at least 20 obvious names I forgot.
Can you really put Oscar ahead of these guys in an all-time prime p4p list?
I think it'd be a stretch to include Oscar even on a top50 all time list.