Quote Originally Posted by Swice
What would be the point of a rematch at this point, besides to satisfy the bruised ego of Margarito. Williams clearly won the fight and there wasn't any controversy besides the ones manufactured by Margarito fanboys. And I say fanboys because fans of Margarito know he lost but also know he put up a great show and will come back, fanboys are too obsessed with Margarito to see the difference.

Also judge the fight on its own merit. I hear people saying "if Margarito started faster" well if he did then we have a different fight don't we? If he started faster their is a chance he could of won, but a chance is far from a foregone conclusion. Who knows what other factors would have come in to play.

Williams went for volume of punches, Margarito went for power, in a fight where neither fighter went to the canvas landed more will probably win you the fight. Also neither fighter looked troubled at anytime in this fight.

Also shouldn't the true thorn in his flesh be Daniel Santos? Both times they fought a cut stopped the fight. One was ruled a No Contest and the second one was a Technical Decision for Daniel Santos. Seems to me that there is more history and controversy in their fights than with a clear cut win by Williams.
Stop talking nonsense. Nobody is causing a controversy. I'm merely saying a rematch should happen at some point because Tony deerves it. To say there should not be a rematch when:

Margarito went through dam litigation to give PW a fight when he didn't have to(although some idiots here were saying Tony was "ducking" PW)

It was a close fight.

There have been rematches were guys were KTFO.

If there is not going to be a rematch at this point,then I definitely don't mind but if there is,I don't see where all this BS about Margarito has to work his way back,what would the point be nonsense comes from.

It's got nothing to do with being a Margarito "fanboy",I was the one of the first to come hear and congratulate PW and say he won. And why should Santos be his thorn? Tony is a natural 147 pounder,went up and lost in a fight most thought he won. He doesn't want to go back to 154,not yet anyway so I don't see the relevance of bringing up Santos. Plus the fight was in Santos backyard.

Well Press Row can see fighters reactions and see if they are hurt more although I agree ICE,I don't think anyone can give that fight to Margarito either. When I scored it 115-113,I was giving Tony the benefit of the doubt in some rounds. I can see 116-112 too.