Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
Yo HitmanDonny,you've been to some Margarito fights?!? Which ones?

And I didn't say you're not allowed to speak hypothetically,go back and read it with your eyes open. And you're saying Margarito win's have been over smaller guys,again... So ALL of PW's wins at WW are not as impressive because he's bigger? And even if you said Tony was a bad fighter,I couldn't care less,everyone is entitled to their opinion but when statements are lacking in validity,that's what I find annoying. Dude,your points don't even make sense!

Quote Originally Posted by killersheep
I could see Margarito at #4 or 5 or even 6 and see valid arguments being made, what I don't understand is why he doesn't move up to 154, he has the build to be stronger there, and there isn't nearly the competition at 147.

I mean really who's left at 154?

Cory Spinks
Vernon Forrest
Joel Julio
Carlos Baldomir
Jamie Moore
Sechew Powell

He would have a great chance of beating most of those guys easily.
I've never seen him fight against a slick boxer, so I don't know how
he would do against Spinks.
Forrest wouldn't be able to bring it.
Against Julio it would be a repeat of his fight against Cintron.
Against Baldomir, his courage and durability wouldn't match up to Margarito's activity
Against Moore again the volume would be too much.
Sechew Powell would be an entertaining fight, but Margarito should be able to take it quick.

Hey KS,you know your my brother BUT you're so way off here!! Why is Margarito going to move to 154 when:

147 is his weight class

The bigger names are at 147

There is more $$$$ to be made at 147

He just made his highest figure in his career at 147

And he has shown he can hang with some of the best at 147.

PW and Kermit have the build to be stronger at 154 too....I'm just not understanding this whole Margarito to move up logic,it's senseless imo. The ONLY reason he should move up is if he cannot make weight.

I was in the Arizona a couple time in 2003 and i managed to catch him fight Maurice Brantley n the dude Hercules Ki...whats his name.
I'm not dealing with hypothetical situations here firstly
I must be a be seriously paranoid and delusional if this statement isn't condemning me for speaking hypothetically.
What im trying to illustrate to you El Gamo is the fact that Margarito beats opponents by using what he has, his size. He out muscles them. Now here is my main point. When You take away his size advantage and his ability to rough opponents up he has very little to compensate. In other words, when fighting a fighter unaffected by his size his limitations as a boxer are exposed.

As for the fact that you find my posts annoying due to lack of "validity" id like u you back that up. I feel i have tried to reinforce all of my points. If my posts don't make sense why do you disagree so vehemently.
Is it because you feel i'm wrong or is it because your'e trying to discredit them so you don't have to argue against them?