Quote Originally Posted by Bx730NY
It's funny how people say Mosley would have taken care of Cotto in his prime, therefore, it wasn't that big a deal, although Mosley was still active and racking up victories. Cotto won by UD.

I guess that means that DLH would have beaten floyd in his prime and convincingly since floyd got a split decision against him. DLH had 1 fight in like 3 years leading up to that against a guy with zero defence and you could clearly see he wasn't sharp against floyd.

My point is you can't assume anything and the fights have to be fought. You mention a guy like Cotto, who has better wins at Welter, and floyd's fans try to laugh it off like floyd is too good to even bother.

All you have to do is look at their common opponents and see who won more impressively.
The SD vs Oscar De La Hoya was total crap i had Mayweather winning easily by 4 points, at Super Featherweight Oscar De La Hoya would have never ever have beaten Mayweather. You forget Mayweather was fighting at a weight class he had never fought at before.