Well one of them is well passed it and the other is IMO just not ready.

If I had to choose between the two I'd say Tito purely as a fan who thinks it would be a solid fight. Even though Tito don't deserve the fight.

I also think Tito may have a decent shot if he can make 160. If Tito wants to continue fighting he has to go to 160 cause he ain't doing anything to any of those bigger guys. But at 160 his power will still be a factor and he looked pretty sharp against Jones till he got cought.

He can beat Pavlik because even though he is a very strong and solid fighter, he is also bery basic, jab, right hand, bit of a shaky defense come forward fighter. Tito use to eat these kinds of fighters for breakfast. But this is now not then and Pavlik's work rate and intensity will most likely overwhelm Trinidad in the end. I will say this. If that was Tito who got Pavlik hurt in the seccond round of the Taylor fight, I guarantee Pavlik would not have made it out of that round.