How Do You Rate The Welterweights ??

[Taeth]

I agree with your list for the most part. From 5-10 to me is interchangable, but I think the top 5 is concrete.

1. Cotto
2. PBF
3. Margarito
4. Quintana
5. Paul Williams

PBF is still the #1 p4p fighter in the sport today, no question, but Cotto has done a hell of a lot more at WW IMO.

If you consider the ODLH fight a WW fight of sorts then COtto definitely hasn't done a hell of a lot more than Mayweather this weight class

Mayweather's list would be MItchell(Who cares), Judah(same as Cotto), Baldomir(better than Gomez), ODLH(better imo at this stage then Mosley), and Hatton

Cotto has Quitana(respectable, Urkal(who cares), Judah( same as Mayweather), MOsley(not as good as ODLH), and the joke Gomez