Quote Originally Posted by artest2000
if both fighters were at wealter weight.

I don't think Roy Jones Jr ever fought at welterweight so this would be a very hard match to judge (career started at 160). But Pernell Whitaker made so many offensive geniuses look stupid trying to hit him ( Chavez, De La Hoya, Mcgirt). He was the best defensive fighter I have ever seen, but Roy Jones had every tool. To hard to call because there is too much of a weight difference.