Quote Originally Posted by hattonthehammer View Post
Quote Originally Posted by ICB View Post
Quote Originally Posted by hattonthehammer View Post


Castillo wasnt half as effective in those middle/late rounds as they were making out, sure he was the busier fighter and hurt floyd on a few occasions. But they gave like 7 of those last 8 rounds to JLC when floyd had taken at least 3 of them.

Another instance of lederman judging with his heart and not his head was the marq-barrera fight.

Everyone could clearly see marquez was winning the fight with ease accept for harold who was scoring every single close round to MAB.

I gave all but 2 rounds to JMM and was relieved as fuck when the judges also saw it that way as i was briefly beggining to think i was going mad
I thought Barrera vs Marquez was a very close fight personally and theres no way on earth Marquez won 10 rounds out of 12, and i just can't see how you could have Mayweather winning 3 rounds after the 5th round, i would be curious what rounds you gave Mayweather after the 5th round.

Dont remember

Am quite sure i gave the last 2 rounds to PBF, and had it 114-112 for mayweather.

Watch the barrera-marquez fight without the commentary on and you`ll see exactly what i mean. Judges tend to give sympathy points out for fighters who are doing just not quite enough to win rounds in succession.

But if you scored every round in terms of scoring shots and dominating a fight you would have to say marq won the fight with some ease.
Must admit I thought that the Barrera - Marquez fight was much closer than a 10 round to 2 round beating. I also think that Jay Nady made one of his biggest mistakes ever in this fight (and thats saying something). When Barrera floored JMM he didn't call the knockdown and deducted Barrera a point for hitting him while he was down! Now this turned a 10-8 for MAB into a 10-8 for JMM which could have changed the fight in a big way. I agree that Mayweather won a close fight with Castillo though and I think ODLH came closer to beating Mayweather than Castillo IMO.