Quote Originally Posted by eagle View Post
Quote Originally Posted by DaxxKahn View Post
Gotta love when we get a new guy who talks out of his ass...Vic is not near a P4P top 10 fighter...good win over Mijares yes but still....Doniare dominated him...he outboxed him then KO'd him....Has Vic improved since?...Yes a bit but so has Nonito so I see a rematch going the same...If Vic went near 122lbs and managed to get a fight with Marquez or some miracle Vazquez either man woukd bring him into a war and Vic has no chance of going toe to toe with either...he would find out quickly the difference between fighting Kirilov, Majares and Catubay then one of those two men...
I think Vic has a good chance v Donaire. He was careless in first fight, it happens. I thiink he was getting on top at the time of the KO, and this led to his lack of defense. Darch has his faults no doubt but kinda annoys me how no one really gave him a chance against Mijares, yet when he KO's him Mijares wasnt that good anyway...

Im not saying your the worst for this at all, u have many good points, but i think some others should give Vic more credit than he is getting. Sure Vic talks shit, always has, but he just KTFO a ring top 10 P4P guy. Dont happen that often.

I mean if a more popular fighter did the same, say Arce for example, he'd get tonnes more credit.

Well first I do not remember saying or could you show me anywhere did I ever say "Majares was not that good anyway"....

Second a puncher like Vic always has a chance...Hell Tyson had a "Chance" against Lewis but did anyone who knows anything really think he would win from punching power alone?

I just do not think that the win over Majares puts him in the P4P list...

I remember a thread not long ago where we spoke of the P4P list and I stated clearly that I do not think that just because a fighter holds 1 win over a P4P fighter that they deserve to be put on the P4P list..

There is a difference...

I also still believe that Doniare over all is a better fighter then Vic....

Lets put it this way...Darchinyan other then a mention here or there has not pushed for a rematch with Doniare...and Doniare has stated several times he would sign in a second...

Vic chose to move on on weight...so what does that tell you?