If Hatton beat Pacquiao is he P4P No1?

[ICB]

Pac is number 1 P4P. If Hatton beats Pac he becomes P4P #1. Simple logic.

I disagree totally Vernon Forrest beat Shane Mosley, who was P4P number 1 at that time. Infact he dominated the P4P number 1 fighter at that time, and he never come close to being P4P number 1.

And to my knowledge whenever a P4P number 1 fighter has been beat, the other fighter who beat them have never become P4P number 1. But i would put Ricky Hatton in the top 5 easily. And like Sonny just said by your logic if ODLH beat Manny Pacquiao, he would become P4P number 1 aswell ? do you see how flawed that logic is ?