Pacquiao has the better resume. Pound for pound Barrera, Morales, and Cotto are all three better than anyone Floyd has faced. Im not taking the JMM fight into consideration because obviously he doesnt belong at 147.
Rubbish. Name one fighter that Manny fought that could have beaten Diego Corrales at the time he fought PBF. Corrales would have done to Cotto what Margarito did to him earlier, and without paddings. He would have destroyed all the fighters Manny beat, and then some. His long reach and power would have devasted everyone on Manny's list, and he would have pulverized Manny.

The problem with you guys, is that your hate for PBF has the effect of lobotomizing your brains. You have to be a Steinbeck's Lennie to assert that Barrera, Morales and Cotto were better than Diego Corrales before he was destroyed by a young Mayweather.

I agree with the general analysis of the thread starter, but feel that he is taking it easy on Mannie because of the Public sentiment. That sentiment surrenders logic in pursuit of emotionalism. This is a situation in which one athlete proposed random drug testing prior to their athletic engagement. The emotional reaction from PBF haters is presented as though PBF demanded that Manny do something he was not prepared to do. I mean I get cognitive dissonance from reading some the reasonings and rationales being presented to defend Manny's ducking out of random drug testing. Because that is, in effect, what he did. He ducked out of random drug testing, and then filed a lawsuit to ostensibly regain his good name.

A little advice for Manny and his infatuated assembley. Lawyers and pussyfooting businessmen file lawsuits to regain their good names. Fighters accomplish that with their fists.