Quote Originally Posted by maracho
Quote Originally Posted by jtrock
Quote Originally Posted by maracho
Thank you for agreeing JTroc. I mean really, what other boxer in history could get a P4P rating after only fighting mediocre opposition like Zab Judah, Sharmba Mitchell, Arturo Gatti, Henry Bruseles, Demarcus Corley, Philip N’dou, Victoriano Sosa for the last THREE FRIGGIN YEARS.
Ok maracho who is better p4p then Floyd right now??Who deserves his crown??

You mean who do I think can kick his boodie? Hmm lets see, I think Margarito, Kostya Tszyu, Joel julio, Oscar, Clottey, Costillo, Colazzo,  can all beat him.

If I were commisioner then we would surely find out.

As for as skills go, I think that Spinks and Eric morales have have as much boxing skills as PBF but that does not mean that they can beat less skilled fighters.

Better P4P (SKILL wise) crowns right now should go to fighters like Hopkins, Toney, Rafael Marquez ,Barrera, Calzaghe, and finally Winky Wright (who showed it in the draw against bigger stronger Taylor)
1) Julio is an UNPROVEN Prospect

2) Floyd beat Castillo 2x

3) Tszyu is to busy dancing and helping Russian fighters who are down on there luck

4) Clottney? Dosent even exist in Boxrec

5)Hopkins is a Hall of Famer and one of the best ever but is retired and always had a nitch of his own..Most will agree he hasnt been #1 PFP in about 4 years



6) You must be a Hatton fan and are Trying to make yourself feel better about his questionable win over collazo

7) I love James Toney but at heavyweight and 240lbs he is pound for pound baddest man at the buffet

Wright to me is in the top 5 PFP

9)Calzaghe needs momentum which unfortunately his body betrays him to often but is a stud anyway top 10 PFP

10)Barrera is on his way down not on his way up albeit he still is a force

11) Margarito is as mobile as a piece of construction equipment and cant keep up with Floyd let alone out box him and anyone who thinks Floyd will stand there all nite and Let Tony hit him is sadly mistaken

All in all I respectfully  agree to disagree on your analysis of Floyd and your PFP