Quote Originally Posted by DaxxKahn View Post
Quote Originally Posted by The Fightfan View Post
1. Marciano - the record speaks for itself - nonstop punching and tremendous heart.
2. Louis - Simply awesome.
3. Holmes - the most underrated HW ever. A complete package and the finest left jab's ever.
4. Ali - the most overrated HW of all time in my mind. Many contraversial desicions just given to him.
5. Foreman - Powerful sonofabitch
6. Dempsey - an animal
7. Frazier - not stop workman.
8. Holyfield - David vs. Goliath mentality always loved his fight's.
9. Lewis - As he got older his skills were amazing and could give anyone above him on this list a licking.
10. Tyson - An awesome talent in his youth but f**ked it all up as soon as he signed with Don King.

Marciano at #1??....Moore, Charles and Walcott are the biggest names on his resume (Please we can not include Louis he was waayyyy past it and the one meaningful fight he had in the 7 years prior to fighting Rocky was a loss to Charles).....Can't see how Marciano possibly could be rated above Louis, Holmes, Ali, Lewis, Johnson, Dempsey, Frazier, Foreman...
It is the simply fact he did what no other heavyweight has done. He beat everyone that was in front of him. Regardless of who he fought he still beat all of them and in KO fashion. Now if we are talking who can beat who then maybe he will slide down the list. But for me he retired undefeated and he deserves the nod at #1.