How high would you rank Manny in ATG if he beats PBF?

[Gandalf]

745th ATG IMO. I hate hypothetical what if's like this. All conjecture with no real meaning behind them. I guess this, I guess that. It's like guessing at a card, sure you have a chance of getting it right, but nobody really knows how two different ATG's would fare against one another. "Oooh, he is 52". "No, he is 54!".

I say who gives a flying fuck.

If you don't want to discuss who is better than who and who would win mythical match ups, it really limits the point of having a 'forum'

Quite true.