Tarver vs James toney (at their best)

[Hulk]

Prime for Prime i would pick Toney to win quite clearly.

In his prime he is superior to Tarver in pretty much every way.

At this point, Tarver would win clearly.

Toney has been done for a few years now.

Agree with the first half.

But, we won't know if Toney is truly finished until after his fight with Lebedev.

[Master]

They should fight each other now at heavyweight, that would be interesting.

[Pugilistic]

Prime for Prime i would pick Toney to win quite clearly.

In his prime he is superior to Tarver in pretty much every way.

At this point, Tarver would win clearly.

Toney has been done for a few years now.

Agree with the first half.

But, we won't know if Toney is truly finished until after his fight with Lebedev.

he's done mate.

Toney was outboxed by Sam Peter a few years ago in the rematch and arguably lost to Fres Oquendo.

His fight against Lebedev will prove it some more.

[jon09]

Well the trash talking would be very entertaining; Probably more then the fight itself, which would be won by Toney by wide unanimous decision.