The best

[RohanKnight]

Sorry Imp i dont think so he only had to beat Tony as he had beaten RJJ, how do think Ward and Froch will go.

reverse the roles. Would a closer to peak RJJ 34 year old beat a 40 year old Calzaghe coming out of retirement? Of course he would.


I think therein lies a truth in the argument. I cant believe that anyone who has seen RJJ fight can think he wouldnt take Calzaghe in a fair fight.

[Mr140]

I think Calzaghe did more then enough to get the win off Bhop and as for Hopkins his reign at Middle weight was damn near as bad as Calzaghes at supermiddle weight. I mean Hopkins still getting the big wins but at mw his best win is what Oscar or Trinadad and those guys did not belong that high at all. As for Jones he also had a fair share of weak fighters he beat up. I think you could argue Calzaghe as the top smw of all time but his atg is kinda hard to put he sure is not the greatest but he is one of them.