I think Davis has much more upside than Rashad but still seems too raw particularly with the long layoff. Rashad's striking looks real good against average punchers (Tito) but against good strikers he can get owned (Rampage). I expect at this point he can strike better than Phil and his wrestling is more than likely on par w/Davis. Phil gets the nod on athleticism but barring he has stepped up a level while on the shelf I think Rashad grinds out a UD with a couple scare mixed in.