Quote Originally Posted by wacko3205
Quote Originally Posted by shza
Quote Originally Posted by wacko3205

IWO, there's no one out there right now that could give Calzaghe the type of fight that your'e speaking of...not Jones, Kessler, Wright, Hopkins, Taylor, or Johnson.
I'll agree that Calzaghe would probably take Roy now (though he would have been KTFO by Roy 10 years ago). I didn't see this fight with Prince whatever his name was, but Roy looked like absolute shite in his last 4 fights before that (yes, including Tarver I). But I think even now Hopkins would dominate Calzaghe. Calzaghe's a good fighter, but he's never been in there with anyone with half the tools Hopkins has.
Calzaghe would be a hard fight for Hopkins but honestly...I think that Joe would win it.

Jones especially.
You are WAAAAAAAY overrating Calzaghe off of his win against Lacy. I guiess its because Hopkins and Jones Jr are so close to Lacy in style right and the move up in weight would do nothing to Joe why look at the wonders it did for Gatti against a supposed non puncher Yeah Roy nor Hopkins would beat Calzaghe