Quote Originally Posted by Dark Lord Al View Post
Quote Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales View Post
here are a few, give me your opinions on how you think these fights would go down

Miguel Cotto Vs Tito Trinidad (at 147) - the closest fight on here IMO, it would be Cotto's superior movement and boxing ability Vs Trinidad's power, stamina, and increasing pressure down the stretch, if Cotto could jab and move and neutralize Trinidad's offense while working the body, then he could get a UD, if not than Trinidad by late TKO

JC Chavez Vs Shane Mosley (at 135) - Mosley's chin, speed, and power at 135 IMO would have made the difference, would have been a war but IMO Shane would take it by decision

Bernard Hopkins Vs Sergio Martinez (at 160) - B-Hop would just outbox and counter Martinez also winning by decision

Nonito Donaire Vs Wilfredo Gomez (at 122) - Bazooka IMO is one of the biggest punchers in the history of the sport as well as one of the greatest (if not the greatest) jr featherweights/super bantamweights of all time, IMO he would have pounded out Donaire in 7
I like Cotto but in my opinion Tito would have torn him a new A , koed him inside 4 rounds with multiple knockdowns.
that all depends, if Cotto was to use his movement and jab as he did against Margarito he would have Trinidad turning and basically giving up his footing and his power in doing so, it would have been a lot more competitive and technical than most think, obviously if Trinidad would have been able to corner and bang well he would definitely hurt Cotto, but the question is would he?
Quote Originally Posted by armyash View Post
Vargas vs Mayorga when both in their primes. I think it would have been a good war with Vargas winning winning around the 9th. At his best he would have had too much for Mayorga and I feel he was the better all round fighter.

Multiple knock downs and plenty of toe to toe action.

When they did fight for real, Vargas was not in great shape and already had 1 eye on retirement. It's a shame this fight didn't happen sooner.
agree, add in he had an already permanent back injury, but in Mayorga's defense the fight happened when he also was past his best and at a weight where he wasn't very effective at (16, but IMO a young Vargas would probably ended up wearing him down

Quote Originally Posted by Althugz View Post
Pretty much agree with all of your outcomes..I fancy Cotto to take Trinidad if he can avoid the monster left hook. It would be the same gameplan when he fought Mosley.
i saw it as a mixture of Mosley and Margarito II, but if Trinidad was able to wear down Cotto to the point Mosley did in the final round, he probably would have gotten him out of there