What your side should look like...

ST: Rooney
LW: Young CF: OX or Milner RW: Sturridge (would play more ST as the back & CM would rotate out to the right to whip in crosses)
CM: Gerrard, Parker or Barry
LB: Cole CB: Cahill, Jones RB: Johnson/Richards
GK: Hart

Skill, speed, youth...those win you matches!