I dont doubt Floyd is a cut above, but that doesnt earn you greatness, you only have to look at Roy JJ. He needs to beat the elite fighters around him. The fights are there for him, he has the opportunity to leave a very fine legacy. I think it all depends on just how much it means to him. Would he fight Winky Wright for peanuts if it guaranteed his legacy?
On a tangent, how do you think Oscar will be remembered (assuming he retired now)? Up there with the Big Dogs?