@ Fenster.

I think Calzaghe would've likely beaten all of them, but as for the other 4 anything could've happened on the nights. I'd envision Froch having a better chance to beat any version of Eubank than the Benn who fought McLellan upon second thought, however. Collins imo wasn't quite on the same level as any of the others, though his style would match up very well with Froch so can't rule him out there.

Froch and Benn would have been savage, hard to imagine both men wouldn't have been badly hurt at some point. My first take was that Benn probably wasn't durable enough to beat Froch, but he was sooo dangerous while being attacked and probably hit a good deal harder, perhaps moreso than anyone Froch has fought as well.