Scoring solution

[erics44]

There are problems with this system though:

1) Combubox is not accurate, it seems just as prone to human error as the judges

2) What happens if one fighter lands 1000 punches in round one, then nothing for the next 11 and get's beat 11-1 on rounds, but has a better punch stat record? Combubox over a whole fight doesn't give an accurate account of what happened.


Somethign needs to be done, I'm just not sure that is it

im sure they could still do it round by round

biggest issue with using it is it doesnt take anything else into account

[cnote111]

Here is my Idea:

Go with 5 judges instead of 3.

3 of them are Ringside and 2 of them in a sound proof booth watching on a HDTV.

After the fight you take all 5 score cards and remove the 2 cards that have the widest margin from one another..

Leaving you with the final 3 score cards to use.

Example:
Judge 1 Ringside - 118-110 Fighter A - Remove
Judge 2 Ringside - 116-112 Fighter A
Judge 3 Ringside - 116-112 Fighter B - Remove
Judge 4 Booth - 115-113 Fighter B
Judge 5 Booth - 115-113 Fighter A

[erics44]

Here is my Idea:

Go with 5 judges instead of 3.

3 of them are Ringside and 2 of them in a sound proof booth watching on a HDTV.

After the fight you take all 5 score cards and remove the 2 cards that have the widest margin from one another..

Leaving you with the final 3 score cards to use.

Example:
Judge 1 Ringside - 118-110 Fighter A - Remove
Judge 2 Ringside - 116-112 Fighter A
Judge 3 Ringside - 116-112 Fighter B - Remove
Judge 4 Booth - 115-113 Fighter B
Judge 5 Booth - 115-113 Fighter A

decent idea

[GOAT]

Don't need no solution for a fixed exhibition show, seraphanx. But I'm certain you knew that, didn't you?

[Seraphanx]

Don't need no solution for a fixed exhibition show, seraphanx. But I'm certain you knew that, didn't you?

Yeah. Disappointingly I did.

[IamInuit]

Compubox is the village idiot

Put them in sound proof booths away from all the distractions and give them the same angles we are given as viewers.

[Andre]

Here is my Idea:

Go with 5 judges instead of 3.

3 of them are Ringside and 2 of them in a sound proof booth watching on a HDTV.

After the fight you take all 5 score cards and remove the 2 cards that have the widest margin from one another..

Leaving you with the final 3 score cards to use.

Example:
Judge 1 Ringside - 118-110 Fighter A - Remove
Judge 2 Ringside - 116-112 Fighter A
Judge 3 Ringside - 116-112 Fighter B - Remove
Judge 4 Booth - 115-113 Fighter B
Judge 5 Booth - 115-113 Fighter A

Good idea and have small screens in front of the judges ringside too so that when the ref or the back of a fighter blocks their view they can use it.

Fights are sometimes too close between champs for them to be allowed to miss even one clean shot.


Also they should be accountable for their scores in front of a panel that will ban them if their scores are too wide of the mark,make them do their job properly or get a ban from large events until they prove themselves worthy.