It's pretty crazy that this has even become a legitimate question because comparing Froch's career to Cotto's would be laughed off three years ago. If Froch beats Kessler in a rematch, beats Bute again, and then has one more key victory, he has a good shot at the Hall of Fame. At one point, I doubted Cotto's resume for the Hall of Fame, after having thought more about it, I believe he's probably in there now. I would like to see Cotto earn one more victory on the big stage to solidify it. Bottom line, both are top quality.