Who was more of a threat to a klitschko? rahman or peter?

[Hulk]

Precisely. Also lets not forget Rahman completely outboxed David Tua, even as a big fat fatty.

Tua was 245½ lbs also.

For chris byrd tua was 233lbs, for ike he was 226lbs and for the 1st rahman fight he was 224½ lbs, so tua was hardly in the best shape for rahman II was he?

There 1st fight was a better guage. And also factor in that tua destroyed maskaev and ruiz who both beat the rock.

Sam Peter was a colossal disappointment. He clearly lost to James Toney in the first bout, then came back as a much smarter fighter in the rematch and legit won that one.

And yes he and Maskaev had a disgraceful bout that resembled two drunks fighting outside a bar, and Peter ended up getting the better of it.

Peter's outing against Jameel McCline was also less than stellar.