Who is the greatest in your opinion??

[Bookkeeper]

1 Sugar Ray Robinson
2 Henry Armstrong
3 Muhammad Ali
4 Willie Pepp
5 Roberto Duran
6 Jimmy Wilde
7 Benny Leonard
8 Julio Cesar Chavez
9 Roy Jones Jnr
10 Harry Greb

You having Chavez #7 on your list and not having Whitaker at all should be illegal

It's based on the fact that Chavez was past his prime when he fought Whitaker - it's all about opinions afterall

Very true, I love to debate. But the only way you can say a fighter is beyond his prime is if he has either loss or has showed signs of slowing down, at the time of the fight Chavez had done niether. He had a brilliant performance before and after the Whitaker fights so how can you say he was out of his prime.

I dont't think any fighter has ever been in their prime after 13 years and 88 fights as a pro, just the way I see it.

Very funny. Fighters such as Mosley, Lacy, Maywheather, Taylor, Ried had tons of fights (some in the hundreds) far before they ever even turned pro, what does that mean? That means if you are fighting part time boxers (boxers who cant live off of their wages so they have to work other jobs) it's very easy to build a record like that, and it would not take 13 years I tell you that much. Add the fact that Chavez is only a year and a half older than Whitaker you dont have much. I won't take anything from Chavez because he was a great fighter but prime or no prime Pernell Whitaker was better, he proved it time and time again.