Calzaghe vs Jones Jr or Mayweather v Mosley?

[imp]

Bando, just answer this, was JC performance against jones a masterpiece and a defining moment in JC career?

Yes, there will always be question marks over JC opposition but he has achieved a great deal.

Would i prefer to have had roy jones career or JC?

Its got to be roy jones because he was a pound for pound champion and would have been a serious threat and a far better boxer than JC.

Roy went through four divisons and yes he did beat a heavyweight ruiz who beat holyfield and then came down again and beat tarver!

Look at the journey and risks Roy put his body through to achieve all this!

JC is undefeated. He is a great boxer with amazing handspeed and duracell battery stamina and when i watched him fight kessler i wanted him to loose but found myself so impressed with his movement and boxing that im glad he won, but cant you see whats happening with the protege' nathan cleverly..its history repeating itself.

[IamInuit]

Jones was done when he fought Cal.
Shane was done when he fought Floyd.
It matters not how Shane looked against a man that was busted before he entered the ring. Or lobotomized.
Shane and Floyd at lightweight would have been something else before he jumped for Oscar.
Would have been nice to see Roy hang at 168 a little longer and fight Cal.
Both fights mean squat really.

[Dia bando]

Bando, just answer this, was JC performance against jones a masterpiece and a defining moment in JC career?

Yes, there will always be question marks over JC opposition but he has achieved a great deal.

Would i prefer to have had roy jones career or JC?

Its got to be roy jones because he was a pound for pound champion and would have been a serious threat and a far better boxer than JC.

Roy went through four divisons and yes he did beat a heavyweight ruiz who beat holyfield and then came down again and beat tarver!

Look at the journey and risks Roy put his body through to achieve all this!

JC is undefeated. He is a great boxer with amazing handspeed and duracell battery stamina and when i watched him fight kessler i wanted him to loose but found myself so impressed with his movement and boxing that im glad he won, but cant you see whats happening with the protege' nathan cleverly..its history repeating itself.

I go for Joe, because he new it was time to walk away, Roy on the other hand great fighter damages
himself, and his great carer by carrying on.