Ring Magazine New top 10 P4P

[armin]

Yeah I was sitting at work and saw that and I was just thinking wtf...joke

[AdamGB]

Their Belt and P4P list mean a lot less now that they are ownedby a promtional company.

Broner at FIVE?!

[CutMeMick]

I did a quick P4P list yesterday but I wasn't satisfied with it. So here's my updated version.

PBF
Ward
JMM
Sergio
Nonito
Pac
Bradley
Mares
Wladdy
Froch

[DavilaJones]

Froch? Don't get me wrong I love the man because he fights anyone anywhere and more often than not he wins. I'd put him in number 10 if he wins againt Kessler for sure.

As for me I agree with the rest, though I would put Wlad over Mares (damn lowblowing bastard....) and put replace Froch with Vitali

[Spicoli]

When did Oscar and company elect Al Haymon to the rankings board. Man. That's really just terrible. These dumb asses REALLY do think he is Floyd

p4p is really just a hollow marketing tool now. I haven't bought a copy of Ring in at least four years.

[Beanflicker]

I have another problem with the list besides Broner that no one mentioned.

...Why is Pacquiao still on the list? Don't get me wrong, I still think hes one of the top 5 best guys in the sport in terms of his in-ring ability, but like everyone has been saying it's about accomplishment.

Pac is coming off of two official losses, the latest obviously being a vicious KO loss. I don't care how good you are, the top 10 p4p list should be reserved for guys who are currently at the top. If you're coming off of back to back losses, you shouldn't even qualify for top 10.

Why is he ranked over the Klitschko bros, who have ruled their division without a loss for 8 years or more? Or an undefeated guy who beat him just two fights ago (regardless of whether the decision was right or wrong, Bradley got the nod).

[RussellScott]

I see BoxRec has Pac at 15 P4P.. a slight over-correction

[jon09]

The funny thing is that he was not even ranked in his weight division for the Ring and now he is #5 p4p. Wow

[ono]

Froch? Don't get me wrong I love the man because he fights anyone anywhere and more often than not he wins. I'd put him in number 10 if he wins againt Kessler for sure.

As for me I agree with the rest, though I would put Wlad over Mares (damn lowblowing bastard....) and
put replace Froch with Vitali

No way. Froch has beaten Pascal, Taylor, Johnson, Dirrell, Abraham and Bute.

Vitali, as dominating as he has been, has beaten a load of puddings.

[Julius Rain]

I still have the same top 5

Pac
JMM
PBF
Donaire
Sergio

not in order I just don't see how these guys can not be in the top 5 considering their whole career and capabilities.

[Second2None]

I did a quick P4P list yesterday but I wasn't satisfied with it. So here's my updated version.

PBF
Ward
JMM
Sergio
Nonito
Pac
Bradley
Mares
Wladdy
Froch

Bradley...what has he done?
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.

[CutMeMick]

I did a quick P4P list yesterday but I wasn't satisfied with it. So here's my updated version.

PBF
Ward
JMM
Sergio
Nonito
Pac
Bradley
Mares
Wladdy
Froch

Bradley...what has he done?
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.

@Second2None regardless of how it happened or wether you like the decision he does officially have a win over Pac. So he has to be there. However the win itself and the way it happened does not merit him a top sport for me which is why I put him that low.

I'd like to see what your list looks like.

[gest12645]

Broner in the top 5? lol top 10? nope . Maybe in the top 20. Other then Broner being there, it is a good list. I think ring magazine is forgetting the Broner vs Ponce De leon fight

[Second2None]

I did a quick P4P list yesterday but I wasn't satisfied with it. So here's my updated version.

PBF
Ward
JMM
Sergio
Nonito
Pac
Bradley
Mares
Wladdy
Froch

Bradley...what has he done?
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.

@Second2None regardless of how it happened or wether you like the decision he does officially have a win over Pac. So he has to be there. However the win itself and the way it happened does not merit him a top sport for me which is why I put him that low.

I'd like to see what your list looks like.

Agree, but to an extent. My list its pretty much identical to yours only problem its that I would probably have rigondeaux instead of bradley.

[CutMeMick]

I did a quick P4P list yesterday but I wasn't satisfied with it. So here's my updated version.

PBF
Ward
JMM
Sergio
Nonito
Pac
Bradley
Mares
Wladdy
Froch

Bradley...what has he done?
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.

@Second2None regardless of how it happened or wether you like the decision he does officially have a win over Pac. So he has to be there. However the win itself and the way it happened does not merit him a top sport for me which is why I put him that low.

I'd like to see what your list looks like.

Agree, but to an extent. My list its pretty much identical to yours only problem its that I would probably have rigondeaux instead of bradley.

I was ok with you saying Bradley possibly didn't belong in there that is until you said you'd have Rigondeaux then you just lost me...

Before Rigon there's still guys like Guerrero, Devon and even Viloria whos a 2 division title holder has a better case at P4P then Rigon... But that's just my opinion.