I think both sides make strong cases...

It is my understanding that the hall of fame is for the "greats" of the sport.
@Freedom : Was talking with someone else about that myself on FB yesterday seems they just go with the flow of things and don't really keep track of who beat who or something...


Also on that note Jorge Arce should get in when he retires.
He was a huge draw here in the States & in Mexico, multiple titles, blood & guts to this day, long career as well.