I saw those two fights the same way you did. In hindsight, after seeing how good Matthysse has become, I've attributed my scoring of the Judah fight to me being a Judah fan. However, it is likely that Judah nicked it as Lucas started quite late in that one.
I feel that in a rematch Matthysse would KO Judah or make him quit. The way Judah fought against Khan was embarrassing. Hopefully, he shapes up against Garcia.
Bookmarks