What was the worse scorecard of alltime ????

[bzkfn]

Watch Casamoyer vs Santa Cruz. Every scorecard was terrible as most had it close to a shut out for Santa Cruz

I was there for that one and Casamayor was poor. It wasn't a shutout in my eyes, as there were rounds were neither guy did much, but I still had Santa Cruz winning it.

The worse scorecards I've seen were in the David Diaz-Erik Morales fight. People are probably sick of me bringing this up, but that was one of the worst decisions I've ever seen. I gave Diaz 3 rounds at most, it was utter bullshit to setup a Pac fight.

[Britkid]

Hardy/BelcastroI: European title fight, in Italy; one judge scored the bout 2-0 Belcastro with 10 even rounds...

[Chomsky Acolyte]

Doug Tucker in Mijares-Navarro. Mijares clearly won the fight but Tucker somehow has Navarro winning ... a shut-out. He had the clear loser winning every single round. I've never seen anything like that before or since. I remember the commentators assuming that the announcer must've mixed up the scores and he actually had Mijares winning every round. Unfortunately not.

[Jerry Rice]

Hardy/BelcastroI: European title fight, in Italy; one judge scored the bout 2-0 Belcastro with 10 even rounds...

Lmfao

[Master]

Leonard judge score against Hagler was like 10 rounds to Ray and 2 to Hagler.

[bradlee180]

Hagler vs Leonard in 1987, very controversial scoring.

Years later, because of ongoing arguments between Boxing fans as to who really won the fight, I decided to score it myself just to work out for myself who I thought won.
Gotta take off the fan-hat and put on the judge's hat, become as impartial as possible and score it rd by rd under the scoring criteria of Boxing.

I had Hagler winning 8 rds and Leonard winning 4 rds. Wasn't a close fight at all, but watching it live on ppv, it seemed a much closer fight.
There was a close rd which scored the other way would've been 9 rds to 3 rds.


Classic fight anyway...

[Jerry Rice]

Leonard judge score against Hagler was like 10 rounds to Ray and 2 to Hagler.

This is why De La Hoya took the Hopkins fight, he thought it would be the same, a late flurry after each round would steal it, NOT.

[FinitoElDinamita]

Oscar-Sturm was pretty bad.

Lewis-Holyfield 1 was disgusting

Hopkins-Taylor 1.. I dont even like Hopkins but I thought he was done wrong. Hops was the defending undisputed champ and no way Taylor did enough to take that away from him. Fuckin bullshit.

Oscar-Tito

BTW, i agree with Santa Cruz-Casa.. Funny that Gest mentioned this robbery cuz this was the first fight that popped into my head when i saw this thread. Yea it was bad.

[Master]

Hopkins-Taylor 1.. I dont even like Hopkins but I thought he was done wrong. Hops was the defending undisputed champ and no way Taylor did enough to take that away from him. Fuckin bullshit.

I agree with you that B Hop won the fight but it was close however did the judges score it widely wrong.

[ykdadamaja]

Roy Jones Jr. vs. Park Si-Hun in the 88 Olympics. Those judges should all commit suicide.

The second poorest scoring fight I saw was against Manny Pacquiao vs. Tim Bradley. Those judges should ALL commit suicide. 115-113 from Ross and Ford for Bradley was just sickening. They should be banned from boxing. In fact, 115-113 from Roth was almost as bad because the fight wasn't even that close. Bradley won, at least, 2 rounds... and they were close rounds you could have scored any way.

These were the two most egregious cases of judging fraud I have EVER seen.

The Roy Jons Jr. robbery would go down in history as the WORSE robbery EVER in the sport of boxing. the Olympic committee should give RJJ his damn medal. For real!

Another one, but it wasn't that bad but I would mention it any way, was DLH vs. Trinidad. But I can appreciate why DLH lost- he simply stopped fighting after the 10th round. You can't beat a champion like that- even though he won every other round, and he should have gotten the decision on merit, by at least a 116-112 score, he simply didn't need to run away for the entire fight.

Honourable mention: Hopkins vs. Calzaghe. The fight was 114-113 Hopkins, and a draw at least. But then again, it was a who-cares fight.