Well, Cotto has been marked up and cut before, to be sure. The fight vs Judah comes to mind. He's also taken some bombs and had to come back to win, like in the Ricardo Torres fight. I just feel the amount of swelling and bruising from the Margarito fight wasn't proportional to the amount of punches he took. But again... nothing can be proven. The rematch? Yeah... Margarito was damaged goods. A bit of karma, I guess. What goes around comes around, like they say. Cotto fought a smart fight, and got his revenge. As for Margarito? History will take care of judging him how it should, probably not too kindly. But again... no... I don't think Margarito was a cheater his whole career. But IMO he had become a cheater significantly before the Mosley fight.