Quote Originally Posted by DaxxKahn
Quote Originally Posted by El Phenomena
Fair enough,you think he is over rated without a particular reason why,not my problem,as I pointed out,your arguments were weak....but each to their own.

I gave you my reason just because you dont like them thats your problem...Those are my reasons...I am supposed to change because you think I should and because of your reasons...Thats like saying you should change your opinion because of mine....I think I named at lest 3...READ
Ok I read your list Hatton, PBF, Margarito, Mosley, Gatti.......are you saying that these guys have fought competition in their prime??

Hatton - fought Kostya Tszyu at the end of his career
Gatti - fought Ward when he was at the 50 fight mark, sure he fought a prime PBF, but I wouldn't exactly say it was a
good showing
Margarito - I'm failing to think of a notable prime name.
PBF - #1 p4p probably will never give Cotto a fight
Mosley - sure he beat ODLH, and Vargas....I'll give you that, but he isn't going to fight Cotto either, there is nothing for him to gain there.

There really isn't an apples to apples comparison here. I don't think anyone is saying Cotto is approaching #1 p4p or anything like that, but he is an incredibly solid fighter at 140 and I think he will do better at 147 and by the end of next year he should be fighting the elite names. Maybe then you will be convinced.