Joe Calzaghe is the 2nd most overrated fighter of all time. Rocky Marciano is no.1

[Master]

prime Chris Eubank, prime RJJ, Sven Ottke, Mike McCallum, Steve Collins, James Toney, all blow him out of the water, hell even Nigel Benn would smoke him.

So sorta like a prime Charles, Moore, Louis, Walcot etc etc. Tell you what, you get that time machine on the go and we can put this theory to the test.

Btw the only man that might have beaten Cal at 168 is Jones. Perhaps Langford. And lmfao at Sven. And you call Joe C overrated.......

Brock has gone a little over the top with Ottke and Collins or McCallum was too old at that weight.

[FinitoElDinamita]

He's only overrated by the Brits. Most Americans dont even consider Calzaghe as anything great and they certainly dont rate him that high all-time..

Me personally, Im a huge fan of Calzaghe and i dont overrate him nor do I underrate him. I put him exactly where he belongs which is high up there with Eubank and Benn.. Maybe even have surpassed them.

[IamInuit]

prime Chris Eubank, prime RJJ, Sven Ottke, Mike McCallum, Steve Collins, James Toney, all blow him out of the water, hell even Nigel Benn would smoke him.

So sorta like a prime Charles, Moore, Louis, Walcot etc etc. Tell you what, you get that time machine on the go and we can put this theory to the test.

Btw the only man that might have beaten Cal at 168 is Jones. Perhaps Langford. And lmfao at Sven. And you call Joe C overrated.......

Brock has gone a little over the top with Ottke and Collins or McCallum was too old at that weight.

I like Brock. He's kinda half serious and half looking for a reaction. Like his workouts on the playground. I have to back track a bit because I think Watson would have been a problem for Jones or Cal and the same goes for a prime Eubanks.
My conclusion remains though.