Is Mayweather a all time great?

[fan johnny]

The people who say Money is not a ATG don't like him as a person. That should have nothing to do with the greatness of a fighter. I just use my eyes. What he has done in the ring and who he has beat. JMM is a guy who gave Pacman pure hell. In fact you can make a case that Pac never beat him even at his best. That takes nothing away from Pac it's just JMM is a outstanding fighter. The same guy that Floyd made a fool out of. If that's not great then I don't know what is.

You mean unlike yourself? How can anyone outside mayweather's circle of friends know who he is, when all they see is his persona? So where do you rank Chris John?

[Mr140]

I Rank Mayeather in the top 15 because a lot of fighters over 100 years who have achieved a lot and different eras make it hard to put them all together on a list. Also Hearns i think deserves to be in same sentence as Mayweather head to head he is fucking nightmare for Mayweather and resume i say is the same if not better. I think him icing Duran, out boxing Benitez and Moving up and beating a undefeated Hill who was on a roll and after losing keep going undefeated till Dm. That just as good as anything that Mayweather has done in his career so he lost to Lenonard and Hagler i think Mayweather would to. I don't know why people are down playing Hearns hear he was a great fighter who fought form ww to cw. I think the only fighters i have in my top 10 are Sugar Ray Robinson and Sugar Ray Leonard and then it changes around a lot.